Amara Cay Resort

Location: Florida | USA

Price guide: £££££ £100-£200 per person per night

Easy, breezy and totally carefree, the Amara Cay Resort is the sort of boutique beach hotel you daydream about. Dotted with palm trees and overlooking the ocean, but with plenty of activities up its sleeve, it is sure to cast you under its spell in no time.
Perfect forCouples and families after a beachfront retreat in the Florida Keys
In the knowIslamorada is the sport-fishing capital of the world and offers incomparable marine life, so hop aboard and go fly-fishing with the experts to catch your own dinner

Recommended for...

  • Beach
  • Setting & Views
  • Snorkelling & Diving
  • Hideaway

Hotel Overview

Sense of Place

The Amara Cay Resort sits by the beach on Islamorada, halfway between Key West and Miami.

Rooms at Amara Cay Resort

Inspired by their natural surroundings, the spacious rooms and suites feature wood and rattan furnishings, in cool neutral colour palettes with splashes of ocean blue. Private balconies make the most of the views over the palm-fringed beach and the sea.

Food & Drink

Reelburger's makes the most of Islamorada’s plentiful seafood, such as fish tacos and grilled jumbo shrimp as well as signature burgers and twists on classic desserts such as Key lime pie. The Tiki Bar offers a range of irresistible cocktails. 


The bar is perched next to Amara Cay’s large pool, and there’s also an outdoor whirlpool and a fitness centre, as well as a playground if you are travelling with children. 

Activities at Amara Cay Resort

Swing in a hammock on the stretch of private beach in front of the hotel, bask in the sun on your private balcony or go for a game of bocce. A Mercedes is on hand to scoot you around the island, or if you want to head out on the water, go kayaking or diving - the ocean's reefs and colourful marine life are right on your doorstep, and Amara Cay's dive shop, Sea Monkey's, has everything you need.

Best time to go

Best time to travel

Good time to travel (but some limitations)

Travel is possible (but it’s not the best time)

Travel is not recommended

  • Jan
  • Feb
  • Mar
  • Apr
  • May
  • Jun
  • Jul
  • Aug
  • Sep
  • Oct
  • Nov
  • Dec
Best time to go

Hotel location

The Amara Cay Resort is approximately 2 hours from Miami International Airport.

Stay at Amara Cay Resort on these trips

More places to stay in Florida


call us on 020 7337 9010 to start planning your perfect trip

Make an enquiry

© 2022 Exsus Travel. Experts in luxury tailor-made holidays.

Exsus Travel Limited t/a Exsus Travel. Registered in England and Wales at this address: 1 Burwood Place, London, W2 2UT. Company No. 3385363. VAT No. 719-221840.

Book with confidence.
All the flights and flight-inclusive holidays on this website are financially protected by the ATOL scheme. When you pay you will be supplied with an ATOL Certificate. Please ask for it and check to ensure that everything you booked (flights, hotels and other services) is listed on it. Please see our booking conditions for further information or for more information about financial protection and the ATOL Certificate go to:
We are a member of ABTA (ABTA No. Y6561) which means you have the benefit of ABTA’s assistance and Code of Conduct. We provide full financial protection for your money.
International Passenger Protection (IPP)
In accordance with the Passenger protection policy for insolvency cover in respect of the Package Travel & Linked Travel Regulations 2018, all passengers booking with Exsus Travel are fully protected for the initial deposit and subsequently the balance of all monies paid to us, including repatriation costs, arising from cancellation or curtailment of your travel arrangements due to the insolvency of Exsus Travel. There is no requirement for financial protection of day trips, and none is provided. Your booking is insured by IPP Ltd and its panel of insurers. This insurance is only valid for passengers who book and pay directly with Exsus Travel. If you have booked and/or paid direct to a Travel Agent for a holiday with Exsus Travel please request proof of how the booking is secured as this will not be covered by IPP Ltd in this instance.
This insurance has been arranged by International Passenger Protection Limited and underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Europe SE. For further information please go to
Claims procedure: you must notify IPP as soon as practically possible giving full details of what has happened quoting the name of your Travel Operator to: IPP Claims at Cunningham Lindsey, Oakleigh House, 14-15 Park Place, Cardiff,  CF10 3DQ, United Kingdom. Tel: +44 (0)345 266 1872.
Email: or online at